Standing in the beauty aisle, it’s easy to feel confused—unable to discern between the many options available, offering similar, yet somehow different concerns. Mascaras in particular keep me puzzled: what separates the best lengthening mascaras from volumizing or lifting formulas?
With so many types of mascaras available, even I, as a beauty writer, sometimes wonder what it all means. But experts say these aren’t just buzzwords—they’re essentially a quick guide to what each formula will do for your lashes. “Lengthening mascaras are formulated to visually extend the lash rather than thicken it,” pro makeup artist Catrina Breitweiser tells Vogue. “They typically use lighter formulas and specialized brushes to separate and elongate each lash, as opposed to volumizing mascaras, which focus more on density and fullness.”
Vogue’s Favorite Lengthening Mascaras
Suddenly, it all clicks—as someone with a thick spider-lash phobia, perhaps I’ve preferred lengthening mascaras all along for a more natural enhancement than a full-on falsie effect, or as Breitweiser describes that “effortless, wide-awake, long lash look.” Fellow pro makeup artist Lauren D’Amelio Ventre agrees, sharing that she relies on these formulas for clients who want added definition without heaviness. Below, shop the nine best lengthening mascaras, backed by experts and editors alike. You’re just a few swipes away from your most fluttery lashes yet!